Grade: B+

MEDIUM RISK

Replace

Item: Replace
Rating: 70
Author: SupplementChecker

Last reviewed: April 14, 2026

Replace has a SupplementChecker.co trust score of 90/100, which is an A+ grade, indicating a LOW risk level. Replace products are third-party tested, holding both NSF Certified for Sport and Informed Sport certifications. This indicates a high level of banned substance testing, making Replace a relatively trustworthy brand.

Replace Trust Summary

Trust Score: 70/100 (Good)
Grade: B+
Risk Level: MEDIUM
Third-Party Tested: Yes (NSF, Informed Sport)
FDA Recalls: 0
Adverse Events: 21

Replace has a trust score of 70/100 (Good). The brand is third-party tested by NSF and Informed Sport, has no FDA recalls on record and 21 adverse event reports.

Where to Buy Replace

Purchase from trusted retailers. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Buy on Amazon Buy on Herbspro Buy on iHerb

Check another brand:

e.g. Nature Made, Thorne, NOW Foods...

Check

Red Flags

⚠Elevated FDA adverse event reports (21)
⚠No GMP certification visible

Verified Strengths

✓NSF Certified for Sport — banned substance tested
✓Informed Sport certified — every batch tested

Certifications

NSF CertifiedInformed SportThird-Party Tested

Third-party testing means an independent laboratory has verified this product's contents, purity, and potency match what's on the label.

FDA Record

FDA Warning Letters

Recalls

Adverse Reports

Is Replace Third-Party Tested?

Yes — Replace is NSF-certified. This means an independent laboratory has verified that the products' contents, purity, and potency match their label claims. Replace holds certifications from: NSF, Informed Sport.

Is Replace a Good Brand?

Replace scores 70/100 (B+) — this is an average score. There may be room for improvement in testing transparency or certifications. Replace has a clean FDA record with no warnings or recalls. The brand holds third-party certifications (NSF-certified), which is a strong quality indicator.

About Replace

Replace is a sports nutrition brand operating independently within the US. The founding date of Replace is unknown. They focus on providing supplements for athletes and fitness enthusiasts.

Product Specialization

Replace specializes in the sports nutrition category. While specific product types are not listed, they likely offer a range of supplements commonly used in sports and fitness, such as protein powders, pre-workouts, and performance enhancers.

How Replace Compares

Compared to other sports nutrition brands, Replace's trust score of 90/100 is relatively high. For example, Optimum Nutrition, another popular brand, has a similar trust score and also carries NSF Certified for Sport certification. Other brands like Myprotein may have lower trust scores and fewer third-party certifications. Consumers should compare the certifications and testing practices of different brands when making purchasing decisions.

Testing & Certifications Explained

Replace's NSF Certified for Sport and Informed Sport certifications are significant indicators of product safety and quality. NSF Certified for Sport means that the product has been tested for banned substances and contaminants, ensuring it is safe for athletes to use. Informed Sport certification means that every batch of the product is tested for banned substances, providing an even higher level of assurance. These certifications demonstrate a commitment to providing clean and safe supplements.

Buying Guidance

Given Replace's high trust score and third-party certifications, it is generally a safe brand to consider. Consumers can purchase Replace products from various retailers, both online and in physical stores. Always verify the product's certification status on the packaging before use.

Frequently Asked Questions

Has Replace had any recalls?

No — as of 2026, Replace has zero FDA product recalls on record. Replace received a trust score of 70/100 from SupplementChecker.

Are Replace supplements third-party tested?

Yes — Replace supplements are third-party tested. They hold the following certifications: NSF Certified for Sport, Informed Sport. Third-party testing means an independent lab has verified the product's contents, purity, and potency match the label claims.

Is Replace safe?

Replace received a trust score of 70/100 (grade: B+, risk level: MEDIUM). This score is calculated from FDA records, third-party certifications, adverse event reports, and transparency practices. No FDA warnings or recalls are on record.

Is Replace a good brand?

Replace scores 70/100 (grade: B+) — this is an average score. There may be room for improvement in testing transparency or certifications. They hold third-party certifications (NSF-certified), which is a strong indicator of product quality. No FDA warnings or recalls found.

Get FDA Recall Alerts

We'll notify you when FDA recalls affect supplement brands you care about.

Compare Similar Brands

Brands in similar categories with comparable trust profiles. Compare certifications, scores, and safety records.

85/100

Lower rated

BACX

Grade A • Higher score

85/100

Lower rated

Soccer Supplement

Grade A • Higher score

85/100

Lower rated

KURE

Grade A • Higher score

85/100

Lower rated

SCIENTIFFIC NUTRITION

Grade A • Higher score

85/100

Lower rated

Engineered Nutrition

Grade A • Higher score

Want more comparisons? Browse our supplement categories or check our buying guides.

How We Calculated This Score

Every brand starts with a baseline score of 70/100.

Points added for: Third-party certifications (NSF +15, USP +15, Informed Sport +10), publishing lab results (+10), clean regulatory record (+10), 10+ years in business (+10), organic certification (+5).

Points deducted for: FDA warning letters (-25), product recalls (-20), high adverse events (-15), no third-party testing (-15), proprietary blends (-10), no GMP (-10).

Score is capped at 0-100. Grade and risk level are derived from the final score.

See our full scoring methodology and data sources for how each signal is measured.

All data sourced from FDA.gov, Health Canada (LNHPD / recalls-rappels), NSF.org, USP.org, and publicly available brand information. Last updated: 5/1/2026.

Promote Your Trust Score

Embed this badge on your site — it displays Replace's verified trust score and links back to this profile page. Helps show buyers you're transparent about third-party testing.

Small · 220×110

<iframe src="https://supplementchecker.co/embed/replace/" width="220" height="110" frameborder="0" loading="lazy" title="Replace trust score by SupplementChecker"></iframe>

Medium · 320×160

<iframe src="https://supplementchecker.co/embed/replace/" width="320" height="160" frameborder="0" loading="lazy" title="Replace trust score by SupplementChecker"></iframe>

Large · 420×210

<iframe src="https://supplementchecker.co/embed/replace/" width="420" height="210" frameborder="0" loading="lazy" title="Replace trust score by SupplementChecker"></iframe>

Paste the snippet anywhere on your site. The badge updates automatically when Replace's trust score changes.

Own this brand? Contact us to update your information.

Want to find supplements you can trust?

Third-party testing is the single best indicator of supplement quality. We analyzed Replace and 500+ other brands to find the ones that actually prove what's on the label.

See the best third-party tested supplements →